Osman Ozbulut headshot
Environment

A UVA Civil Engineer Helps the NYT Explain Buildings’ Collapse in Venezuela Earthquake

When a powerful “doublet” earthquake — two shocks in quick succession, centered about 3 miles apart — struck Venezuela on June 24 this year, the destruction was widespread. 

In the state of La Guaira the second 7.5-magnitude quake toppled 80% of the buildings. Even so, the near immediate collapse of four public housing apartment buildings, comprising 10 towers, had The New York Times and other media outlets asking why. The buildings were less than 15 years old and housed approximately 3,200 people. 

The shocking, wholesale disintegration of these modern towers — while six others in the complex stood — could not be blamed on the violent shaking alone.

To help explain what happened, New York Times reporters consulted several structural engineers, including Osman Ozbulut, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Virginia and expert in earthquake-resilient building design.

For its article, How Venezuela’s Public Housing Towers Were Built to Fail, the Times’ investigative team examined thousands of images of the rubble, as well as video of the event, which they shared with Ozbulut and other experts for analysis.

From the evidence, the writers concluded there were “dangerous mistakes and shoddy construction that doomed the buildings, turning them into some of the quake’s densest pockets of death.”

One mistake, the government’s decision to ignore warnings about building so close to an active fault, was compounded by design choices and construction shortcuts. Venezuela’s leaders were in a hurry to replace thousands of homes destroyed by mudslides in 2010.

The buildings cannot afford to be strong in one direction.

But one design flaw stood out to Ozbulut as the likely reason the towers failed so quickly and completely. Rectangular columns in the buildings that fell all faced the same direction. While meant to provide strength, the wide face is the weaker side when pushed against, so designers typically vary column orientations to resist force coming from multiple directions.

It may seem like a small design choice, but rectangular columns can become a building-wide vulnerability. The buildings cannot afford to be strong in one direction.
OOOsman OzbulutProfessor of civil and environmental engineering

“It may seem like a small design choice, but rectangular columns can become a building-wide vulnerability,” Ozbulut told the Times. “The buildings cannot afford to be strong in one direction.”

UVA Engineering asked Ozbulut about his involvement in the Times story and lessons engineers can draw to prevent similar tragedies. Below, he explains his contributions to the article and expands on how his research aims to not only keep people safe during an earthquake, but to help them return to normal living more quickly after the event. 

Why did the NYT contact you?

New York Times reporters had interviewed me following the 2023 earthquakes in Turkey, my home country. After those earthquakes, I was trying to understand why so many buildings had collapsed and shared a series of social media posts explaining structural failures and the lessons we could learn from them.

What was your involvement in examining the buildings in Venezuela?

Screenshot from a NYT Facebook reel showing footage of the eathquake and 3D models explaining the building's collapse.
This New York Times Facebook reel shows a 3D reconstruction revealing why the towers fell.

I had read some initial coverage of the Venezuela earthquake, but the reporters provided the specific photographs and videos that became the basis for our discussions. One particularly striking question was why four buildings collapsed while two others at the same site, which faced a different direction, remained standing.

Important information was missing, including original structural drawings and ground-motion records at the site. The Times team developed reconstructed plans from the information they could gather, which helped us examine the buildings’ structural layouts more closely. I helped interpret how features such as column orientation and the distribution of lateral stiffness and strength could have influenced their response to shaking, while explaining the limits of what we could conclude from the available evidence.

Part of my contribution was translating these engineering concepts into language that a general audience could understand. The reporters were committed to understanding the technical details, so this was a thoughtful, iterative process.

How could your research inform affordable housing in earthquake-prone regions?

My research focuses broadly on improving the earthquake performance of buildings to reduce the social and economic disruptions that follow these events. The goal is to protect lives while also limiting damage, displacement, costly repairs and interruptions to everyday life.

Actual earthquakes provide a real-world laboratory for this work. Studying why some buildings perform well while others fail helps us identify vulnerabilities, test our assumptions and develop better approaches for future construction.

Your work focuses on resilient infrastructure. What does that mean?

An important distinction is that minimum seismic code requirements generally prioritize life safety. Even a properly designed building can sustain substantial damage during a major earthquake and remain unusable for an extended period. Our field is working toward a higher performance objective called “functional recovery,” which aims to restore a building’s basic intended use within an acceptable time after an earthquake.

How does your research support this goal?

We develop technologies that absorb earthquake energy and help buildings return toward their original position after shaking, reducing damage and permanent deformation. We aim to make these improvements practical and economical, with modest additional upfront costs and potential savings over a building’s service life.

Although my research is not specifically focused on affordable housing, its broader goals are relevant to housing and many other building types. Every human life is precious, and the consequences of an earthquake extend well beyond the immediate danger. Helping people remain in or return to their homes, workplaces, and schools sooner is central to building more resilient communities.

Resilient and Advanced Infrastructure Laboratory graphic

Design, Materials, Smart Technology

Osman Ozbulut directs the Resilient and Advanced Infrastructure Laboratory, where his research team works to make civil infrastructure more resilient through improved design, innovative materials and sensing technology. He also serves as director of graduate studies for UVA’s Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering. 

Ozbulut is an associate editor of the Engineering Structures journal and Journal of Intelligent Material Systems & Structures. He is also a member of the American Society of Civil Engineers and American Concrete Institute.

Read more research news from School of Engineering.

This article was originally published here: https://engineering.virginia.edu/news-events/news/uva-civil-engineer-helps-nyt-explain-buildings-collapse-venezuela-earthquake